Critique Group Update


Just wanted to give everyone a quick update on the critique group list!

As of yesterday the Google spreadsheets are up-to-date in listing both current groups and members actively looking for groups. If you’ve sent a request and haven’t heard back from me that you were added to the spreadsheet, or are awaiting an answer from an email you’ve sent, please let me know at shelley (at) shelleykoon (dot) com (please replace the (at) with @ and (dot) with a period!)

Right after conferences my email becomes extremely backed up and as much as I hate it, I can  miss things. In addition I recently migrated to a new computer and while I think I managed to migrate everything over to the new machine, I never assume that I’ve managed to capture everything. Thank you all for your patience!

I do want to mention that I’ve been getting quite a few “have you found me a group yet?” emails and/or emails asking if I know of members in <insert town and state here> looking for a group. While it’s certainly fine to send such an email, you’re always going to get the same answer from me which is, “Please check the spreadsheets for groups or members in the area you are inquiring about and contact those groups/members directly.” When it comes to “coordinating” the critique groups for the region, I am simply the keeper of information which will give you a starting point to locate or start a group that works for you.

So what do you do if you have checked the spreadsheet and have yet to find anything? Here are five options/ideas to help you out:

1.)    Start a group. If your goal is a career in writing, being in a critique group is going to be a very important aspect of your job. Thus sitting back and waiting until a group forms is counterproductive to your goal. When I started my first critique group it was done at an SCBWI gathering and while a number of members had signed up on the sheet to indicate they wanted to join a critique group, no one was steeping forward to say “I’ll start this”. I’d never run a group before but I knew having one was important so I stepped up. You can too! Need help? I’m always here to talk you through the steps (and off the ledges!).

2.)    Expand your options. Looking strictly for a large group? Why not look for one critique partner to start with? Demanding face-to-face? Consider Skype or Google Hangouts. Bottom line – be flexible and consider all critique group options to get yourself started.

3.)    Don’t be afraid to look for local all genre groups. The first critique group I joined was an all genre (in this usage meaning both adult and children’s writers) group. While all genre groups may have bigger challenges with picture books due to the writing/art balance that some writers may not have experience with, novels tend to follow very similar structures in all genres. I found my all genre group’s comments to be just as valid as the comments from my children’s writer group. To find local groups, start with your local libraries and arts council/guild.

4.)    Visit the MD/DE/WV Region Critique Group spreadsheet often! The spreadsheet has grown from around 30ish members when I began it a little over a year ago to over 175 members currently! There are big jumps in numbers after conferences but that doesn’t mean there aren’t new people being added in between so be sure you check in often!

5.)    Attend SCBWI events and conferences. There is always something going on within SCBWI on this coast! Be it with the MD/DE/WV region or those nearby, you can get out and meet other SCBWI members and find critique partners. Never be afraid to mention you’re looking for a group when meeting fellow writers, you never know which of them may be looking for the same thing.

Lastly I’d like to add that if you would like to be added to the spreadsheet please fill out the form located on the regional site.

If you are a current registered member, please make sure the info I have for you and /or your groups is correct!

Now – go out there and find a group!



About Shelley Koon

Artist and author - visit me at my site listed below.
This entry was posted in Critique Group Tips & Info. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Critique Group Update

  1. ljbluwater says:

    Hi Shelley –

    I didn’t realize there was a list of people looking to be part of a critique group. I would love to be added to that list.

    I went to the website to fill out the form but was unable to access it. I write picture books.

    Also, how can I view the Google spreadsheets or is that only for admins?

    Thank you.


    • Shelley Koon says:

      Laura –

      You can email me and I can send you the info. Once you have been added to the spreadsheet you’ll be sent the link to access the spreadsheet.

  2. Sue says:

    Hey Shelley,

    That’s tremendous growth! Thanks for the update, and especially all you do do to support our critique groups. It’s a big job and only your giant spirit, heart, energy, and data skills can make it happen.

    i;m sure more groups will be bllooming this summer!


  3. Linda Sweitzer says:

    Just wanted to let you know that I am moving to PA this Friday, so not sure about the critique group. I would not be able to meet personally, but might be able to help out online.   Thank you, Linda

  4. Pingback: The passing of our Critique Group Coordinator torch! | As the Eraser Burns

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.